In Durban’s Cato Manor, a middle-aged woman cares for her ailing mother. That simple domestic situation is the surface of an ambitious new film that asks harder questions underneath: who gets to keep their history, whose memory counts as real, and what happens to a nation that never properly mourned the end of apartheid.
The film, “Mother, you have not died yet. But you will. And when you do, you will finally be alive again,” is the feature debut of Advik Beni, a South African filmmaker, programmer, and teacher based in Los Angeles. An experimental documentary shot on warm, cotton-pulpy celluloid, it blurs the line between fact and fiction while remaining grounded in the factual. It had its world premiere at the FID Marseille film festival this year, where it won the Audience Award, and recently celebrated its North American debut at the Camden International Film Festival.
At its center is a question with weight for an entire community: what does it mean to be Indian in post-apartheid South Africa? The country’s first Indians arrived as indentured laborers in the 19th century to service the growing sugar plantations in KwaZulu-Natal. Over generations, the group wove its identity into South Africa’s industrialized cultural landscape, yet its relationship with Black South Africans has been tumultuous. Many of those frictions and wounds converge in Cato Manor, a neighborhood originally inhabited by former Indian indentured laborers, and the place where the film is set. Durban bears the weight of historical racial violence between Blacks and Indians, and of the preservation and decay of its first inhabitants’ heritage.
Beni, interviewed by Tsogo Kupa, traces the project back to conversation rather than cinema. The protagonist is Beni’s auntie, and the film began as a discussion about how to explain South Africa to anyone outside its borders. It became something wholly different when the aunt’s mother passed away, and the idea of reenactment entered as a kind of experiment. Beni describes a model of filmmaking focused on process rather than product, one that is non-hierarchical and hybridized, allowing exchange between everyone on the project. The people enacting and reenacting parts of the film gave what they wanted and blocked out what they did not want. For Beni, the gaze becomes problematic only when something is pasted onto a subject; with genuine dialogue, participants are authors of the work as well.
That ethic extends to the film’s treatment of the archive, a theme with civic resonance. Beni describes a false dichotomy between those who want to preserve the archive, often institutions, and those who want to burn it, and a search for the in-between. Speaking as a South African Indian, Beni notes that their archives are not held in institutions in any tangible way. Instead, they live in recipes passed down, in the photo albums of loved ones, and in people telling stories. The film takes official archives, such as the 1949 riot image, and creates a bricolage collage effect by placing alongside them oral histories, thoughts, and imaginaries that exist outside the structures that certify what is real. “Outside of us putting it forward and saying, ‘No, it’s real,’” Beni says.
The medium itself carries political meaning. Beni came to Los Angeles for the California Institute of the Arts, which teaches filmmaking on celluloid, and insisted on shooting on Super 8 and 16 despite the anxiety of shipping film from South Africa to LA for processing. The physical medium, Beni explains, was not designed for black and brown skin; its exposure and chemistry were calibrated with white test subjects. Because Kodak boycotted South Africa, Beni’s people never had the privilege to own film in the ’60s, ’70s, and ’80s, leaving access only to white oppressors who came from places like the UK to shoot their skin. Using that same medium now to shoot people and places never shot on it felt, Beni says, like a small rebellion.
Sound design deepens the film’s texture. Beni recorded with five microphones, capturing the spatiality of Cato Manor, a place visited constantly growing up because that is where Beni’s granddad and auntie lived. The sounds are constant: a dog from next door, somebody skating down the road, a taxi passing with music. In the experimental essay sections with voiceover, the sound captures a liminal space, an ancestral realm where the mother is alive and dead at once, her voice settled while the surroundings are not.
The film’s deepest concern, and its most public one, is grief. Beni points to the final sequence, which looks at the 1949 riot and the 2021 riots. The cyclicality is disheartening, and it led Beni to a conclusion about the nation itself: South Africa is a country that did not properly grieve for the end of apartheid. “We kind of put a plaster over a bleeding wound and hoped for the best,” Beni says, and roughly 30 years later those wounds are slowly opening again. The hope, for Beni, is that South Africans can find a place of tangible repair and tangible shift. In the meantime, routines of gardening, cutting wood, and prayer give people a sense of knowing even when the larger world around them is unknowing.
Durban itself is a character in the film, complicated by holding the highest concentration of Indian people and a tenuous relationship with Black residents. Cato Manor was pivotal in the fight against apartheid, and the film draws on the riot archive and a barbershop that has been in Beni’s family for 70 years. Beni observes a lack of integration that is harmful in the long run, fed by the system, a lack of care from the city, and missing infrastructure, forces that are inseparable from each other. The 2021 riots layered disgruntled exhaustion on top of those tensions, and they came out in ways harmful to people.
Whether the film reaches a global audience remains an open question for Beni, who acknowledges how specific Cato Manor is to South Africa. But the tensions between two communities that were both subjugated, at different levels, ring true elsewhere, even in Los Angeles. What Beni will stand strong on is the need for South African filmmakers to find their own language and their own vessels for storytelling, rather than following French or American models. “We don’t want to be fetishised,” Beni says. “We want to be telling it our way for our people.” There are things to figure out, Beni adds, and the time to do it is now.