Ireland Face Springbok Reality Check After Fiji Win

Ireland Face Springbok Reality Check After Fiji Win

Fiji's display exposes flaws before the Springboks arrive in Dublin

A 43-15 win over Fiji sent Ireland’s supporters home from the Aviva Stadium satisfied, but the sobering message from the afternoon concerns what lies ahead. Next Saturday, Andy Farrell’s side face South Africa, the back-to-back world champions, in Dublin at 16:40 GMT, and the man who knows both teams best has warned that the margin for error will shrink dramatically.

Jake White, the former South Africa head coach who led the Springboks to World Cup glory in 2007 and was appointed Fiji boss last month, suggested his side had done Ireland a service by exposing weaknesses before the meeting with the world champions. “We probably did Ireland a favour today,” he said after the match. “Ireland deep down know that if they play like that against South Africa, they’re gonna be up against it.”

For the general rugby-going public, the stakes of next weekend’s Nations Championship contest are considerable, and White’s assessment of how the Springboks operate offers a useful guide to what supporters can expect. Fiji frustrated Ireland for long stretches, with the sides separated by only 17-15 at the break, and White argued that his team’s approach mirrored South Africa’s in a telling way. “We were playing a little bit like South Africa to be honest, I think that sums it up,” said the 62-year-old. “We were letting Ireland have the ball and we were happy to defend against them and we were happy for them to try to outwork us.”

The most pointed lesson came from a decision Fiji made in the second half, when the game was still in the balance. White was frustrated that his side opted to take a tap penalty rather than a scrum, a choice he believes the world champions would never have made. “I know how South Africa operate and they would’ve taken that scrum there, they would have backed the fact that they wanted to get [Ireland] a yellow card,” he said. “They would have taken another scrum and another scrum and another scrum, and they wouldn’t have worried about the ref making a call about collapsing or early engaging.”

White, whose full analysis is available via the BBC at https://www.bbc.com/sport/rugby-union/articles/c9e85d7mm0myo, added that missed opportunities close to the line are the kind Ireland cannot afford to repeat. “The five-metre line-outs that we didn’t take opportunities in, and the five-metre scrum and tap penalties, South Africa will turn those into points and I’m sure that Andy [Farrell] and the players will be aware of that.”

Meanwhile, White offered a reading of Farrell’s selection thinking, suggesting the Ireland coach had kept his strongest side available precisely to prepare for the Springboks. “They have been around a long time, and they know what’s coming, and that’s probably why he picked the team that he did because he wanted to make sure that they get a little bit more gun-ready for next weekend,” White said. “The easiest thing would have been to change the team and then they’re probably one game shy of playing South Africa next week.”

Farrell, for his part, acknowledged that the scoreline flattered his team. “Pleased to get the win, especially the scoreline, it flattered us a little bit but having said that you’ve got to work for those points and after 25 minutes you’re down by five points against a side that’s playing pretty well,” he said. He noted that Fiji were winning collisions, strong in the air and on the floor, and dangerous running through the line, while describing the breakdown as “pretty good”. “All in all, we need to understand that wins here when you’re under a bit of pressure, they’re all pretty precious.”

When White’s remarks were put to him, Farrell struck a constructive tone. “We were just saying in the changing rooms that we learned some good lessons and we’ll use them in the right manner for next week,” he said.

One concern for Irish supporters is the fitness of James McNabney. The Ulster back row made a shorter-than-expected debut, coming off the bench and making two huge carries before being forced off with a head injury that rules the 23-year-old out of the South Africa game. Farrell, though, reported the player in good humour. “He’s joking in the changing rooms, he’s delighted with himself for the shortest cameo of a first cap,” he said. “I reckon it’s the best cameo of three-and-a-half minutes or whatever it was on a debut in Irish history really. He remembers the two breaks that he made, so he seems in good spirits.”

Ireland scored 26 unanswered points in the second half to pull clear, but the wider takeaway for fans is clear: South Africa won 24-13 in Dublin last year, and the lessons Fiji taught on Saturday will need to be learned quickly. Can this Ireland side apply them before the world champions arrive?

Q&A

What was the result of Ireland's match against Fiji?

Ireland won 43-15 at the Aviva Stadium, scoring 26 unanswered points in the second half after leading only 17-15 at the break.

Why does Jake White believe Fiji did Ireland a favour?

White, the former South Africa head coach now in charge of Fiji, said his side exposed Ireland's weaknesses before the meeting with the world champions, and warned that if Ireland play like that against South Africa they will be up against it.

What decision by Fiji did White criticise?

White was frustrated that Fiji took a tap penalty rather than a scrum in the second half, saying South Africa would have taken the scrum repeatedly to try to get Ireland a yellow card without worrying about the referee's calls on collapsing or early engaging.

Which Ireland player will miss the South Africa game and why?

James McNabney, the 23-year-old Ulster back row, was forced off with a head injury after a short debut cameo of about three-and-a-half minutes off the bench, ruling him out of the South Africa match.

Related articles

  1. 1 Mzansi Life BBC Bets Big: Celebrity Come Dine With Me Gets Triple-Channel Launch
  2. 2 Mzansi Life Miss SA builds R5m fund to sustain finalists' impact work
  3. 3 Mzansi Life Mother and coach Namhla Siyolo eyes rugby coaching first
  4. 4 Mzansi Life Your vote today shapes local services for five years
  5. 5 Mzansi Life Australia's cricket collapse demands accountability